Harvey Weinstein’s 2020 rape conviction overturned by New York appeals court


Harvey Weinstein's 2020 rape conviction was overturned in New York on Thursday, opening the best way for a brand new trial.

The state appeals courtroom discovered that the choose within the landmark #MeToo trial biased former film mogul Weinstein with unfair rulings, together with the choice to let ladies testify about allegations that weren’t a part of the case.

The courtroom, in a 4-3 determination, mentioned, “We conclude that the trial courtroom erroneously admitted testimony of undisclosed, alleged prior sexual acts towards individuals aside from the complainants of the underlying crimes as a result of that testimony would produce no -Pattern goal not met.”

“The Courtroom compounded that error when it dominated that the defendant, who had no legal historical past, might be cross-examined concerning allegations in addition to a number of allegations of misconduct that painted the defendant in an especially prejudicial gentle. Do,” it mentioned.

Decide Jenni Rivera referred to as the errors “critical” And mentioned that the answer is a brand new check. Weinstein's If prosecutors determine to pursue one other trial, the accusers could also be referred to as once more to testify.

Decide Madeline Singas, in a dissenting opinion, accused nearly all of “whitewashing the information to swimsuit a he-said/she-said narrative” and failing to acknowledge that the jury was allowed to think about Weinstein's earlier assaults.

“This Courtroom continues a disturbing pattern of overturning responsible verdicts by juries in instances involving sexual violence,” Singas wrote.

In a separate dissenting opinion, Decide Anthony Cannataro mentioned the choice was “an unlucky step backwards.”

Weinstein's accuser says, 'Our reality has not been overturned.'

Louise Godbold, who labored in industrial manufacturing and has alleged that Weinstein attacked her twice in 1991, advised NBC Information that her first response to the decision was “a intestine response.”

“Sending messages to different survivors, we're all saying, 'Our arms have been shaking a lot,'” he mentioned Thursday. “All of the concern, panic, and confusion from the unique trauma comes again, and earlier than you even have time to write down down a thought, it's your physique that's reacting.”

Caitlin Dulany, an actress who has mentioned that Weinstein sexually assaulted her in a lodge room through the 1996 Cannes Movie Pageant, mentioned she is “deeply shocked” and “saddened”.

“I feel I'm nonetheless just a little bit in shock,” he advised NBC Information. “I feel there might be a number of deep unhappiness afterward.”

Filipina Italian mannequin Ambra Battilana Gutierrez, who accused Weinstein of molesting her and was captured on tape saying, “I’ll by no means do this once more,” mentioned the choice highlighted the continued failures of the justice system and the courts. Has been uncovered.

Former actor and Weinstein accuser Don Dunning criticized the choice.

“Though I’m shocked that the courtroom threw out Weinstein's conviction based mostly on authorized technicalities, I’m nonetheless proud that I testified and confronted a convicted rapist,” Dunning mentioned in a press release.

A lawyer for producer Alexandra Canosa, who accused Weinstein of rape, mentioned: “Right now's determination by the New York State Courtroom of Appeals is deeply disappointing. “Weinstein is a serial sexual predator and has been discovered responsible by juries in two totally different states.”

Lindsay Goldbrough, a lawyer representing six of Weinstein's accusers, referred to as the decision “a backwards leap for the rule of legislation” that might deter future sexual assault victims from coming ahead.

“To all of the victims of sexual assault who’re damage by in the present day's verdict, I’m deeply sorry,” mentioned Goldbrough, whose shoppers included mannequin Taralee Wolf, who testified that Weinstein assaulted her in her Manhattan condo in 2005. I had raped her by luring her into speaking. A movie audition.

Douglas H. Wigdor, an legal professional who has represented eight Weinstein accusers, additionally condemned the decision, saying it was “a significant step ahead in holding these answerable for acts of sexual violence.”

“Courts routinely admit proof of different undisclosed acts the place they help the jury in understanding points associated to the defendant's intent, modus operandi or planning,” he mentioned in a press release.

Wigdor mentioned overturning the convictions “is tragic as a result of it requires the victims to endure one other trial.”

Dulany mentioned he hopes prosecutors will proceed to pursue the case. A spokesperson for the Manhattan District Legal professional's workplace mentioned it could “do all the pieces in its energy to retry this case, and stay steadfast in its dedication to survivors of sexual assault.”

Godbold expressed concern that the accusers might should relive their trauma.

“It was positively re-traumatizing for them to undergo the trial,” he mentioned. “Speak once more if there's a brand new check.”

He mentioned he hoped New York's accusers would keep in mind that “our reality has not been overturned, even when their convictions have been overturned.”

harvey weinstein
Harvey Weinstein will seem in courtroom in 2022.Etienne Laurent/Pool by way of AFP – Getty Photographs File

Gloria Allred, who represented former “Challenge Runway” manufacturing assistant Mimi Haley, mentioned Haley would take into account testifying once more. Weinstein's New York conviction stemmed from allegations made by Haley and former aspiring actor Jessica Mann.

“I applaud Mimi's braveness and willingness to face up for the reality,” Allred mentioned in a press release.

#MeToo founder Tarana Burke spoke at a press convention on Thursday.

“Moments like this spotlight why actions are crucial,” he mentioned. “And we now have a motion… Nearly seven years in the past, as a result of these courageous ladies broke their silence on this matter, tens of millions and tens of millions of others have been empowered to come back ahead and do the identical. The victory will at all times be theirs.”

Actress Ashley Judd, one of many first ladies to accuse Weinstein of sexual misconduct, mentioned on the press convention, “I stand shoulder to shoulder with ladies whose knees bleed as male sexual violence tears us down. We might, however we stand once more.” ,

Legal professional 'assured' Weinstein's Los Angeles case might be upheld

Weinstein, 72, is serving a 23-year sentence in a New York jail after pleading responsible in 2006 to legal sexual act costs for forcibly performing oral intercourse on a TV and movie manufacturing assistant and third-degree rape for an assault on one other. Aspiring actor in 2013.

The allegations got here to gentle in 2017 following investigative reviews revealed by the new York Times And the new Yorker, Weinstein's sample of sexual abuse and lack of accountability helped gasoline the #MeToo motion.

Weinstein spokesman Judah Engelmayer mentioned Weinstein's camp is “thrilled with the courtroom's determination.”

“We clearly have a protracted highway forward of us in California,” Engelmayer mentioned in a press release to NBC Information.

Weinstein's legal professional, Arthur Aidala, mentioned the choice was a “victory” for his shopper and “each legal defendant in the US.”

Weinstein additionally confronted costs in Los Angeles and was convicted of rape in 2022 and sentenced to 16 years in jail. In that case he was acquitted of a case of sexual harassment.

Evgeniya Chernyshova, one among his accusers within the Los Angeles case, didn’t touch upon the overturning of the New York conviction. However her legal professional, David M. Ring, mentioned he was dissatisfied and that Chernyshova feels unhealthy for her New York accusers.

“Nevertheless, she and I are each assured that Weinstein's conviction for rape in Los Angeles might be upheld,” she mentioned in a press release. “As the one sufferer who has now obtained a legal conviction towards Weinstein, she is going to stand agency and do no matter is important to get justice not just for herself however for all victims.”

Mark Werksman, Weinstein's lawyer within the Los Angeles case, mentioned the overturned conviction was “the proper consequence” and a “nice end result.”

“We encountered an analogous impropriety within the Los Angeles case, the place the choose allowed prosecutors to confess proof of 5 undisclosed allegations of sexual assault,” Werksman mentioned in a press release. “That is extraordinarily unfair and creates confusion the place you may by no means make sure whether or not the jury convicted your shopper due to the charged conduct or due to the uncharged conduct. So these convictions should be overturned.”


Scroll to Top